Milgard Tuscany Windows Reviews

Milgard vinyl windows are a popular choice on much of the west coast. While not considered a top tier window necessarily, the Milgard suite of windows ought to be considered as a very solid mid range option.

Milgard Vinyl Windows receive a 4.0 rating out of 5 -- read 21 Milgard window reviews using the link in the breadcrumbs above. Here you will find links to all of the Milgard Windows And Doors series, along with general price information.

Explore Milgard Tuscany windows reviews, costs, ratings, and warranty information on this vinyl window. The Milgard Tuscany is the premium vinyl replacement window from Milgard and a step up from their Milgard Styleline window. The Tuscany is probably the company's most popular and best known vinyl window series. The Tuscany is a simple looking vinyl window that performs well.

The Tuscany has a more classic look to it than the Style line, along with even site lines, a higher-quality lock, and aluminum spacer, two vent stops, a better quality exterior screen, and a beefier frame. Milgard Tuscany replacement windows cost 10% to 15% more than the Styleline and includes a better locking mechanism, weep holes and spacer system.
The Milgard Tuscany Window Series gets a 4.2 out of 5 star rating.

Review By John M. - Site Editor

Last Update: March 4, 2024

Quality Window Companies

We would really appreciate if you would consider filling out our free form. This allows us to provide you with free consumer info on replacement windows and connects you with 3 quality local price quotes.

We are not incentivized by ANY companies. Send us your bid summaries and we will help you get the BEST DEAL for your particular situation. That’s our personal guarantee to you!

Milgard Tuscany Prices

Homeowners can expect the Milgard Tuscany to cost somewhere in the $500 to $650 fully installed. Milgard Tuscany windows cost 10% to 15% more than the Styleline. Comparatively priced windows include the Ply Gem Pro Series and Reliabilt 3500 Series Windows.

-- Window Itself: $300 to $400 --

-- Installation: $125 to $250 per opening --

-- Window & Installation: $500 to $650 -- *

» More On Milgard Tuscany Prices

Type Of Window
Frame Material
Quality Of Window
Type Of Installation
Number Of Windows
Enter Your Zip Code

Milgard Tuscany Ratings

Milgard Tuscany window ratings with a low e glass and argon fills should get a U-factor of roughly .29 and and an SHGC somewhere slightly lower than this. These are pretty decent ratings, someone in the middle of the road for vinyl replacement windows.

The Tuscany is a more energy efficient option over the Milgard Styleline Series and these numbers should drop to .26 U-factor and .25 SHGC with an upgrade to the 3D Max Glass package.

Milgard Tuscany Window Warranty

The Milgard Tuscany offers a Limited Lifetime Warranty on all of their windows (and doors) to the original purchaser. This covers the mainframe and sill and all components and warrants that they are free from manufacturing defects and workmanship. It covers both parts and labor costs and is transferrable to another owner, although the new owner warranty is only good for 10 years from the original date of purchase. As with all replacement and new construction window warranties, there are a number of exclusions that apply to their products that consumers should read in full prior to purchase.

Tuscany Reviews Or Questions

Do you have a question about the Milgard Tuscany? Our industry professionals can help you get more information on pricing, upgrades, installation requirements, contractor's price bids, as well as help you sort through the quotes and companies you are considering for your next window replacement project. Want to add your Milgard Tuscany windows reviews? Post it here and help other consumers get the information they need to make the right choice for their home.

Milgard Tuscany vs ProVia Aspect

Looking at the Milgard Tuscany and how it compares to ProVia Aspect windows - the Aspect is roughly $75 more in cost per window over the Tuscany.

Paul - Homeowner - Febraury, 2024

Website Editor's Answer

Paul, the Aspect is definitely worth $75 more ovr the Tuscany series. Not even a question in my mind. ProVia Windows Reviews

Editor John - February, 2024

Milgard Tuscany Price Quote vs. Simonton 6200

Hi there, I'm in the Bay Area and just got a couple of quotes from two window companies on replacement windows for a retrofit. I'm choosing to get wildfire windows as there is a city grant program that will reimburse customers up to $5,000. Home Depot and the second company are both pushing Simonton since they offer the double lifetime warranty. Do these quotes sound reasonable as all prices are rising? We would like to keep costs down as much as possible. Any insight on the either of these Simonton series.

Simonton Daylight Max, 12 windows, includes a garage window (wildfire windows) for $14,943
Simonton 6200, 11 windows (missed garage window) (wildfire windows thru Home Depot): $14,273
Milgard Tuscany, 11 windows, tempered (wildfire) Home Depot: $14,981
Thank you.

Sandra - Homeowner - May, 2022

Website Editor's Answer

Sandra, I have noticed that HD's quotes have been really high as of late. I don't know the specifics of your project, but I would say those bids are high. I'd get maybe two more bids from independent companies and see how they comapre before you pull the trigger. I would rather have the 6200 series myself over the Daylight Max or the Tuscany...but they're all pretty close in quality to be quite honest with you.

Here are my Northern California recommendations: [List Redacted -- contact me directly (John) for his list of window options.]

Editor John M. - May, 2022

Milgard Tuscany vs. Simonton Asure And Zen Nirvana

Your site has been so helpful with reviews to narrow things down, but picking windows is proving to be very difficult. Everywhere I look seems to have different opinions on each brand and just when I think I've narrowed it down I read something that makes me start considering one I've eliminated. I'm replacing a patio door, 3 very large slider windows, and 4 small basement windows.

Amerimax comes in cheapest at $5,500, with my choice of Masters or Craftsman with AG3.

The Milgard Tuscany is $6,400, but I think that is for whatever the base level everything is.

The Simonton Asure is $7475 with the "better glass package", but I'm pretty sure I can talk the contractor down a bit on that one if it's the better window.

Zen window's Nirvana is $7415. I keep reading that it's the Soft-lite classic, but based on what was written in the quote it seems to be the pro. Also, I'm not sure if ZEN will negotiate.

Which of these is the best window overall (in Denver, CO)? Is the Nirvana or Asure 25% better than the Amerimax? If they really are superior I don't mind spending the extra money, but if they are all on par, I'd go with the lowest quote.

Marie - Homeowner - February, 2018

Website Editor's Answer

Marie, the Simonton Asure is the company's entry level model and nowhere near what the Soft-Lite Classic or Pro is (I was always under the impression that the Zen Nirvana was the Classic but perhaps it is the Pro -- either way they are very similar windows).

I like the Amerimax Craftsman Portrait windows for $5,500, I would say that window is equivalent to the Milgard Tuscany. This would probably be my pick, although I would try to negotiate with each of them to see how much they will drop the price. Amerimax makes a good vinyl window and patio door.

I would have to say that the Soft-Lite Pro is the better window compared to the Amerimax Craftsman Portrait, but not for that price increase.

Editor John M. - February, 2018

Milgard Tuscany Windows vs Anlin Del Mar

We are looking to purchase window and sliding door, we are trying to make a choice between the Milgard Tuscany and the Anlin Delmar windows. Could you help us with that? Thanks.
Louis - Homeowner - June 30, 2016

Website Editor's Answer

The Milgard Tuscany and Anlin Del Mar are pretty darn close in terms of quality and price (actually the cost might vary, but it shouldn't by much). I like both windows, although I might opt for the Tuscany myself because I feel like Milgard is a bigger name and easier to find installers and parts down the road. Honestly though, this is a personal preference.

I would say make the decision based on the quality of the installers and company who you are working with over the small difference between the window. This will be a bigger factor down the road than the windows (again because they are so close in quality.)

Response From Editor Jim R. - June 30, 2016

Milgard Tuscany vs. Amerimax Craftsman

Amerimax Craftsman or Millard Tuscany replacements? Same installation with new outside moldings etc. Tuscany runs about 1k less for all 7 windows I want replacing, but stuck with do I save a few bucks and have less of a window or is Tuscany just as good?

David - Homeowner - November, 2017

Website Editor's Answer

David, my own personal opinion is that the Amerimax Craftsman Portrait and Milgard Tuscany are equal in quality, construction, and performance. Assuming you like the way the Tuscany looks compared with the Craftsman Portrait, I say save yourself the $1K. In terms of the windows, you are not sacrificing anything. Obviously, the installation company is something to consider as well.

Editor John M. - November, 2017

Milgard Tuscany vs Pella 250

Which would you recommend, the Milgard Tuscany vs Pella 250 vinyl window for a home in Oregon.

Nancy - Homeowner - July 26, 2016

Website Editor's Answer

Nancy, I would definitely recommend the Milgard Tuscany vs Pella 250. Milgard has a better reputation in terms of vinyl windows and the Tuscany is one of my favorite west coast picks for a solid mid range vinyl window. Read more Pella 250 series reviews.

Editor John M. - July 26, 2016

Milgard vs Alside Mezzo

Please rate the Alside Mezzo window and Milgard.

Jim - Homeowner - April 20, 2016

Website Editor's Answer

Jim, the Alside Mezzo is an updated version of their Excalibur - it uses the same frame, but has a different sill. The frame is thinner than their Sheffield model, which is nice. I would put the Mezzo in the mid range vinyl window category. However, as a company, Alside doesn-t have the strongest reputation in general, I would give Milgard the nod in this comparison.

As far as Milgard goes, they make a number of different window models, so I'm not sure which model you were referring to. Their lower end Styleline is probably on par with the Mezzo, while the Tuscany, their most popular, is probably better than the Mezzo.

If it were me, I would get the Milgard Tuscany window in my house over anything that Alside makes.
Response From Editor Jim R. - April 20, 2016

Milgard Tuscany vs Anlin Coronado

Milgard Tuscany or the Anlin Coronado? I'm stuck between which one, any advice? Looking at vinyl double hung frames.
Dave - Homeowner - April 27, 2016

Website Editor's Answer

Dave, the Milgard Tuscany and Anlin Coronado are pretty similar in terms of performance, although I'd probably give the nod to the Coronado series for the number of features and options it offers. If those were my choices (and I like both of these windows), I might pivot from the windows to the installer/company who is doing the work. How do they compare? Reputation? Referrals? Price? Scheduling? Gut feeling?

I think this would be my deciding factor over these two similar windows. Let me know what you go with and what you end up paying so I can share the info with other consumers who may be considering these two quality options.

Additional Milgard Tuscany Windows Reviews

Website Editor's Note

All Milgard Tuscany reviews prior to the year listed above have been archived for the sake of relevancy to homeowners and consumers.

Editor John M.

Type Of Window
Frame Material
Quality Of Window
Type Of Installation
Number Of Windows
Enter Your Zip Code